The same prompt at scholarship level. Read it after the Selective model. Notice the deeper argument and the more grown-up voice. It also treats the other side as a serious view, not a quick reply.
Dear Mr Lee,
There is a particular kind of quiet that has settled over our playground, and it is not a peaceful one. Walk past at lunchtime and you will see rows of students sitting close enough to touch. Yet they are separated by the bright rectangles in their hands, together and entirely alone. Our one phone-free lunch each week is the single hour that breaks this spell. I am writing to ask you, with real conviction, to protect it.
I want to be fair to the other side of this argument, because it is not a foolish one. Phones are truly useful. They let us reach our parents, organise our afternoons and stay close to people we care about. I am not asking you to ban them. I do not believe the answer to a complicated problem is to pretend it is simple. What I am defending is narrower and, I think, more important. It is the choice to set phones aside for sixty minutes a week. In that hour we practise a skill our generation is quietly losing: being fully present with the people in front of us.
Consider what actually happens on those days. Students who normally vanish into their screens are drawn into handball, conversation and invented games. A boy in my year who rarely spoke ended up, almost by accident, running a lunchtime chess club. These are not small moments. Friendship is not an extra that sits on top of school life. It is the very thing that makes a nervous or lonely child willing to come through the gate each morning. An hour without phones does not merely pass the time. It builds the kind of community that no assembly or poster ever could.
There is a quieter benefit, too. Constant notifications keep our minds restless and on alert. A screen-free hour lets them settle. Our teachers have noticed that lessons after a phone-free lunch are calmer and more focused, and that is no coincidence. Attention is not endless. A brain pulled in twenty directions all break has little left for the afternoon. One phone-free hour does not lose us time. It protects the attention that makes the rest of the day worthwhile.
Some will say that a single lunch cannot possibly matter. I would argue the opposite: it matters precisely because it is small and deliberate. It is one visible decision, made together, that says our attention and our friendships are worth defending. Habits are built from exactly these small, repeated choices.
A school is not only a place to collect knowledge. It is where we first learn how to live well alongside one another, and that lesson cannot be downloaded. For the sake of our friendships, our focus, and the fragile skill of simply paying attention, I hope you will keep our phone-free lunch. Thank you for considering the views of your students so seriously.
Yours sincerely,
Priya Sharma